© 1999 Losingmyreligion.com, except where otherwise noted.



Prayer: Interview One
by Darcy West

reprinted by permission


Darcy West: What is the difference between God answering your prayer and God doing what he had planned to do all along?

Disciple: God does all according to His will. In answering prayer, He can say either 1) yes, 2) no, or 3) wait. Still all is according to His will.

Darcy West: Disciple, if his will will be done no matter what, then it will be done whether you pray for it or not, right?

Disciple: No, because Jesus said that you don't receive because you don't ask. Prayer is vital.

Darcy West: God will fail to carry out his perfect will if a person fails to pray?

Disciple: Good question. His will is that none of us be lost, but if we don't accept Jesus as Saviour we will indeed be lost. God will not force His will upon us.

Darcy West: So if it is God's will to heal Mary Smith of cancer, and yet no one prays for Mary Smith's healing, then God will fail to heal her?

Disciple: Another good question. Jesus healed without anyone praying so it would appear, but that also seemed to have to do with faith in receiving the healing.

Darcy West: Disciple, so you believe that the actions (prayer or faith) of people can affect the actions/decisions of God?

Disciple: Could be. You have very good questions. Well thought out.

Darcy West: Disciple. thank you. Since you believe that the actions of people (faith, prayer, etc.) can affect the decisions/actions of God, I am wondering if you believe that God is omniscient?

Disciple: God is definitely omniscient. The Bible says so.

Darcy West: And that would mean that he knows all things...including everything that he is going to do, yes?

Disciple: Yes, the Bible says that. The Bible says that He knew us before we were ever formed in the womb.

Darcy West: If God knows all things, would it be possible for him to experience any degree of uncertainty, whatsoever?

Disciple: I don't believe so.

Darcy West: In order to change one's mind....would you agree that one must first experience uncertainty or have incomplete information?

Disciple: I don't believe so.

Darcy West: What leads one to change one's mind?

Disciple: I think the information can change & lead 'us' to change our minds.

Darcy West: Disciple, what information? New information?

Disciple: New information, or correction of misinformation.

Darcy West: Would an omniscient God ever receive information he didn't know previously?

Disciple: I think people can change their minds for a number of reasons. As for God, He would not sin.

Darcy West: Disciple, what would cause God to change his mind?

Disciple: He would not since He knows all since before the beginning.

Darcy West: Disciple, if God cannot change his mind.....how can his actions/decisions in any way be affected by the prayers of humans?

Disciple: I only know what the Bible says. How about you?

Darcy West: Does the bible say that God changes his mind?

Disciple: I can't recall it saying that He changes His mind, only that He regretted certain things.

Darcy West: If God is omniscient and perfect, why would he do something that he knew he would later regret? If God changes his mind and does things he regrets, how do you know that he won't or doesn't regret having sent Jesus to die?

Disciple: I don't have the answer to that one. That would mean I know the mind of God and therefore am at His level, and we all know what happened to Lucifer when he tried that.

Darcy West: But would you agree that if God does things he regrets, it is quite possible that he regrets ever having sent Jesus and that he will change his mind about offering you salvation?

Disciple: I think you're getting into very dangerous territory questioning the perfect Almighty God.

Darcy West: Disciple, dangerous? In what way are such questions dangerous?

Disciple: Read the Bible, Darcy. Only there & in prayer to God will you find the perfect answers to your great questions.

Darcy West: Disciple, I did that. The book doesn't explain how an omniscient God can change his mind or why an omniscient and perfect God would make mistakes (do things he later regrets).

Disciple: Go back and read it again. This time with the right motive. That's a wrap.

Darcy West: Thank you, Disciple.